Chickashanews.com

Opinion

August 2, 2013

Editor says TEA Party letter was unwarranted

CHICKASHA — Typically I'm not one to respond to letters to the editor. People have their opinions, I have mine and the world keeps spinning.

However, on Wednesday we printed a letter detailing a local TEA Party member's distaste for my article over the party's animosity toward the renewal of 3/4 cent sales tax that is up for vote Sept. 10.

This letter addressed a number of issues that the writer, TEA Party member Joyce Stockton, seems to have with the newspaper. With that in mind I feel it is my duty to address each of her concerns one-by-one in the same way she expressed them.

First, there is the issue of me using the word animosity to describe the TEA Party's opposition to the possible tax renewal. Mrs. Stockton quotes Webster's Dictionary defining animosity as "ill will, tending toward active hostility."

Another definition of the word, as defined by Webster's, is "a strong feeling of dislike or hatred." Tonight, the TEA Party will show a presentation on why voters should cast their ballots against renewal during their monthly meeting. I don't think you try to get people to vote against something you like, so using a word that implies dislike is probably appropriate.

The letter then goes on to detail that as editor, I have the right to oppose conservative views, traditional family values and any view that differs from mine, which I have done in the past.

I agree with everything she says here. I am, on most issues, not a conservative. However, I've never expressed these views in a news article. Any editorial commentary I've made has been in an opinion piece or subjective feature. Alleging that the use of animosity in an article is an editorial slant is downright ridiculous, especially when that allegation comes with only a partial definition of the word.

The next paragraph is a restatement of what TEA Party representative Mark Keeling said in an interview for the story, which so upset Mrs. Stockton. It goes on about the importance of water in a community, and how previous councils have not been good stewards of capital improvement tax dollars.

Just for good measure, I'll say I haven't decided whether I agree or disagree with the TEA Party's request to allocate all the funds generated from this sales tax for water improvement. I will write a column when I do, though.  

The next paragraph states that I, by using the word animosity, have cast the Grady County TEA Party in a negative light, similar to what the liberal national media does. It also says that my choice of words are apparently an effort to divide the community.

I've never really fancied myself a super villain. I've never written a column with the goal of creating a massive divide among voters that inevitably will crush family values and bring an end to conservative Chickasha. I do love political debate. I consider Keeling to be a friend and he and I have had numerous political debates, but managed to maintain our friendship. The thing is, I don't think Mrs. Stockton likes opposition of any kind. These conservative values that she holds so dear tend to blind their believers from progression and reality. Traditional family values are once again mentioned in this paragraph. I can only imagine that this was reiterated to make a point that I wrote a story on how the repeal of the Defense of Marriage Act would affect Oklahoma. She goes on to say the TEA Party are not racist, bigots, tyrants or haters of government.

That's fair. The national media does categorize the TEA Party as the aforementioned taboos, and although I've never even remotely written anything resembling such remarks, I have come out against the TEA Party before.

So since our local TEA Party is so progressive, I look forward to hearing them complain about why the streets on the east side of Chickasha are in such disrepair at the next city council meeting, writing letters to the editor chastising our website and Facebook commenters that called a gay couple we interviewed disgusting and financially backing a candidate for public office.

The last paragraph is my favorite of the letter.

First, Mrs. Stockton says she believes I owe the TEA Party an apology. I was under the impression that I was entitled to my own views according to her political ideology, so I'm a bit confused why I should apologize. That seems a little tyrannical for such a non-tyrant.

Then there is her lament about people calling TEA Party members names. I'm truly sorry if someone has hurt your feelings Mrs. Stockton, but that's the world of politics. If you want to be a force for change, you should prepare for animosity. If it is too bothersome, I suggest you leave the political process to those who can take the heat.

She elaborates on her critiques stating she knows the insults will continue by those who don't support conservative Christian values.

Thomas Jefferson's letter to the Danbury Baptists details the importance of a separation of church and state. It's interesting to me that there is such a religious concern in the TEA Party, when the author of the Declaration of Independence spoke directly against religious involvement in politics. This doesn't seem too American.

Lastly she reiterates that I have a right to write what I want, but asks "what happened to newspapers that wrote the truth and were neutral on issues?"

Madam, we do write the truth. There is no political bias in our news articles. There are simply sources conveying information with transitions separating them. If I had written something that said the TEA Party ignorantly met this tax with animosity, I'd think you'd have a point. But I didn't. Most opinion is generated from adjectives and adverbs, of which there are very few in our news stories, unless they're located in a direct quote.

The truth is Mrs. Stockton, you are guilty of the same misdeed that you're accusing me of. You didn't use all the definitions of animosity in your letter. You picked the one that best fit your argument, and for someone who is so interested in the truth, it seems odd that you would be selective on your version of it.

I do have a solution to our misunderstanding. Drop the facade that the Grady County TEA Party doesn't have leadership and doesn't back candidates. Put someone in charge of media relations and my supposed terrible misrepresentations of the party will stop.

Politics is a game for brave people who put their names and faces in the limelight for better or worse. The effort that the local TEA Party makes to affect change in small convenient doses, is weak. If you want to play in the political arena, you should be ready to bleed, and what I've seen from the Grady County TEA Party is you'll only fight if you can't be hurt. That just doesn't work. It's not the conservative Christian values that yields the party criticism. It's the lack of follow through.

1
Text Only
Opinion
  • Fightin' Words: Lessons from sports, even in tragedy

    This week, Americans got to hear firsthand accounts, some for the first time, of a sporting tragedy, the lessons from which are as poignant as sport itself.

    April 18, 2014

  • Weir speaks on good traffic stops do for society

    On the law enforcement side the county was fairly quiet last month. There was an incident which may not have seemed of great importance to many, but I would take exception to that.

    April 15, 2014

  • The Hero of Haarlem…For the Common Good

    “Trudging stoutly along by the canal,” as the story goes, the eight year old son of a Dutch sluicer was returning home from delivering cakes to a blind man. Humming as he passed the dikes, he noticed that recent rains had made his father’s job even more important.

    April 11, 2014

  • Morning Ralph…Morning Sam…For the Common Good

    Deep in the vaults of Warner Bros. there is a series of Merrie Melodies cartoons featuring Sam the Sheepdog and Ralph E. Wolf.  It has been years since I have seen the animation; however, the tan sheepdog with the unruly mop of auburn hair and the thin brown wolf that bears an uncanny resemblance to Wile E. Coyote (except for Ralph’s red nose and Wile’s yellow eyes) are readily recalled.

    April 4, 2014

  • Fightin' Words: A right way and a wrong way to treat a college players union

    Initially the ruling by the National Labor Relations Board over Northwestern football players' ability to unionize was, at first, the start of a ticking time bomb on college sports.

    March 28, 2014

  • In New Orleans, Katrina victims live out Hollywood eco agenda

    I visited Lousiana recently to do some reporting on Sen. Mary Landrieu's bid to win a fourth term in a tough political year. But before heading to the key parishes that will determine Landrieu's fate this November, I stopped by New Orleans' Lower Ninth Ward to see how rebuilding efforts are faring nearly nine years after Hurricane Katrina.

    March 25, 2014

  • BLOG: America is doing all it can to Russia

    The conservative response to President Obama's handling of the Ukraine crisis is a perfect example of what some Americans need to learn about how the world around them works now.

    March 21, 2014

  • In jam over Obamacare, Dems don't know which way to turn

    When it comes to Obamacare, many Democrats take comfort in polls showing a small majority of voters, or at least a plurality, oppose repealing the Affordable Care Act. To them, that proves the Republicans' do-away-with-it position is out of sync with voters as this November's midterm elections approach.

    March 18, 2014

  • Il Buono, Il Brutto, Il Cattivo and the Common Good

    The term “Spaghetti Western” is used to describe a movie about the American West but directed and produced by Italians and normally filmed in Europe. This motion picture genre has been around for more than 70 years.  Outdoor scenes are often shot in an area of Spain that bears a striking resemblance to the Southwestern United States.

    March 14, 2014

  • Have Bazooka - will travel and the Common Good

    For seven seasons from 1957 through 1963, actor Richard Boone played a gentleman gunslinger named Paladin in the CBS television, Have Gun—Will Travel.  The storyline involved Boone’s character, a highly educated and cultured mercenary whose residence was the Hotel Carlton in wild-west era San Francisco.  Paladin’s business card intimated that he had no qualms about using his Colt .45 revolver or his single action Marlin rifle for hire, wherever his career would take him.

    March 7, 2014