Morgan was detained later in the evening by CPD and questioned about the incident.
He denied cutting or stabbing Gardi, but did admit to having a physical altercation with him, according to the report. Morgan said his girlfriend, Ashley Boyle, arrived at Gardi's home and the couple walked back to their house on 11th Street.
"Morgan advised that while walking home he and Boyle crossed paths with "Cheeto" and that he thinks "Cheeto" is the one who stabbed Gardi and Chance," the report reads.
The report details Boyle's statement, in which she claims she had gone to locate Morgan after her friend, Crystal Postoak, made comments about Morgan being "jumped."
She said she never saw "Cheeto" while walking toward her home with Morgan.
The report states Morgan told CPD he heard "Cheeto" and Postoak talking in the bathroom of his home and "Cheeto" admitting to stabbing someone.
This information contradicted Morgan's initial statement, where he claimed he did not know who injured Gardi and Chance.
An affidavit was submitted to the district attorney's office alleging there is probable cause to file an assault and battery with a deadly weapon charge against Morgan.
Police Chief Eddie Adamson said the incident is still under investigation.